Though business litigation has declined in recent years, corporate lawyers
predict that the frequency of suits may increase in 2009, according to a new
survey of corporate attorneys by international law firm Fulbright &
Jaworski.
The projected increase is likely to come from both a rising trend of wage and
hour litigation and a change in federal law that makes it possible for employees
to file disability-related lawsuits even if their disabilities are correctable
through medication or assistive technology.
The study also found that although litigation is down, nearly four out of
five companies reported being hit with a suit in the past year, and one out of
five organizations face 20 or more of them. Additionally, the overall cost from
lawsuits seems to be holding steady, with 45 percent of companies reporting that
they are spending at least $1 million on litigation costs annually, a slight
uptick from a year ago.
“With a new definition of who is disabled under the [Americans with
Disabilities Act], we expect to see a significant increase in claims over the
next year and a half,” said Butch Hayes, an Austin, Texas-based partner in
Fulbright & Jaworski’s employment and labor practice.
Additionally, Hayes said that wage and hour-related litigation under the
federal Fair Labor Standards Act has tripled in the past decade, and that trend
shows no signs of abating.
“I think [plaintiff] lawyers are becoming more educated about what the laws
allow and don’t allow,” he said. “Some lawyers now take wage and hour claims
almost exclusively.”
Fulbright & Jaworski’s study had 358 participants globally, including 251
U.S. companies and 100 from the U.K. Forty-eight percent of the companies are
publicly held, and 40 percent have annual revenue of $1 billion or more. (All of
the findings cited in this story are for U.S. companies only.)
Pending employment-related lawsuits were cited by 47 percent of companies in
2008, making them slightly more common than contract disputes, in which 46
percent of companies were embroiled. An additional 29 percent faced personal
injury lawsuits.
Overall litigation costs for U.S. companies basically remained stable in
2008, though the decrease in the frequency of lawsuits suggests that they are
costing more. Thirty-nine percent of U.S. companies spent $500,000 or less on
litigation, while 15 percent spent between $500,000 and $1 million, 29 percent
spent between $1 million and $5 million, 7 percent spent between $5 million and
$10 million, and 9 percent spent $10 million or more.
U.S. companies mostly gave themselves high marks for their management of
records, which often becomes a crucial issue in employment lawsuits. Sixty
percent of companies gave themselves a rating of 4 or 5 on a confidence scale,
with 5 being the highest score in that area. Twenty-two percent rated themselves
as fair, and 17 percent gave themselves a 1 or 2 rating, indicating a lack of
confidence in their performance.
—Patrick J. Kiger
Workforce Management’s online news feed is now available via Twitter.